Click the link below for this month's coaching article...
Pastoral Leadership Lessons Every Pastor Learns the Hard Way
by Joe McKeever - ChurchLeaders.com
Joe McKeever has spent decades in ministry and along the way he has learned plenty of lessons that probably could not have been learned from a book or taught in a classroom. They came through leading people, making mistakes, navigating difficult seasons and simply staying at it. He has gathered many of those lessons into this article and I think they give us some good things to talk about together.
This article covers a lot of ground. In fact, there is far more here than we can meaningfully discuss in one sitting. So let’s not try. Read through it beforehand and come prepared to talk about whatever part feels especially relevant to you right now.
Before We Sit Down
Take a few minutes on your own and think about this question: What is one moment early in your ministry that nobody warned you about? Maybe it involved conflict, criticism, loneliness, unrealistic expectations, finances, staff problems, or discovering that loving the church and occasionally being frustrated with the church can apparently happen at exactly the same time. Hold onto that story. We’ll begin there.
Every pastor who stays in ministry long enough develops a private collection of lessons learned through mistakes, difficult conversations, disappointments, successes, and seasons we probably would not volunteer to repeat. McKeever developed his list over decades of pastoral ministry and many of the lessons remain remarkably relevant.
Ministry has not become easier to sustain. Pastors today are navigating burnout, financial pressures, changing congregational expectations, leadership transitions, cultural tension and the growing realization that healthy ministry cannot revolve around one exhausted person. These realities make some of McKeever’s lessons particularly important. Pastors need to learn how to lead themselves, build trust, develop people, navigate conflict, protect their integrity and remain anchored to Christ.
(1) Lead Yourself Before You Lead Anyone Else
Healthy leadership begins with self-leadership. A pastor who cannot manage his own time, emotions, priorities and limitations will eventually struggle to lead others well. Discipline matters. Knowing why we are doing something helps us determine which opportunities deserve a yes, which ones require a no, which battles are worth fighting and which projects can wait.
Healthy leaders also learn to recognize their weaknesses as clearly as their strengths. Ironically, some of our greatest leadership problems can emerge in the areas where we are most confident. Strength can become a blind spot when we stop paying attention to how it affects the people around us. That is why pastors need people close enough to tell them the truth.
We also need time to think. Sermons, decisions, vision, relationships, and problems all require space to process. Constant activity can make us feel productive while quietly robbing us of the reflection necessary to lead wisely. Continuing to learn matters too. Reading, training, coaching and mentorship are not distractions from ministry. They are part of becoming the kind of leader ministry requires.
For our conversation: Where are you currently leading yourself well? Where are you struggling? Is there a weakness, habit or blind spot that deserves more attention than you have been giving it?
(2) Earn Trust Before You Ask People to Follow
Leadership does not automatically come with a title. Trust is earned over time.
One of McKeever’s most important reminders is to earn the right to lead before pushing significant change. Most pastors arrive at a church ready to fix things. Unfortunately, the congregation may not yet be convinced that the new pastor knows what needs fixing. Sometimes wisdom means slowing down long enough to listen, learn the culture, love the people and establish credibility.
Trust is built through ordinary things. Tell the truth. Report attendance, giving, baptisms and other numbers honestly. Communicate clearly. Avoid manipulation and spin. Keep people informed before major decisions rather than announcing something after everything has already been decided.
People can usually handle difficult truth better than leaders imagine. What damages trust is discovering that information was hidden, exaggerated or carefully managed. Healthy pastoral leadership means saying what we mean and meaning what we say, even when the truth is inconvenient.
For our conversation: How would you describe the current level of trust between you and the people you lead? What have you done that has strengthened that trust? Is there anything happening right now that could quietly be eroding it?
(3) Lead With Attention
Leading people well begins with actually seeing them.
Pastoral ministry becomes dangerous when people slowly turn into responsibilities, problems, volunteers, giving units, or names on an attendance report. People want to be known. Learning names, listening carefully, remembering what is happening in someone’s life and understanding what motivates people are not insignificant leadership skills. They communicate that people matter beyond what they can contribute to the organization.
McKeever also emphasizes delegation. Many pastors struggle to delegate because they know they can do something faster or better themselves. They may even be right. But continually doing everything ourselves creates two problems. We become exhausted and the people around us never have the opportunity to grow.
Healthy delegation means giving people meaningful responsibility while continuing to provide appropriate follow-up. We are not hovering over people, but neither are we tossing them the keys and disappearing. We establish expectations, check in, coach when necessary and give people enough freedom to accomplish something differently than we would.
For our conversation: What are you currently doing that someone else could be doing? What keeps you from handing it off? Is it a lack of capable people, a lack of training, a lack of trust, or perhaps a little bit of our own need for control?
(4) Raise Up Leaders and Faithful Followers
One of the clearest signs of healthy pastoral leadership is what happens when the pastor is not in the room.
Our responsibility is not simply to accomplish ministry. It is to develop people who can accomplish ministry. That means giving emerging leaders genuine responsibility, allowing them to make decisions, giving them room to make mistakes and helping them learn from those mistakes.
Sometimes leadership also means knowing when someone else should lead. Another person may have gifts, experience, knowledge, or relationships that we do not possess. Mature leadership does not require us to remain in charge of everything. Sometimes the strongest thing a leader can say is, “You are better equipped for this than I am. You lead and I’ll help.”
The same principle applies beyond our own churches. Other pastors are not competitors. Churches are not competing franchises. We are part of the same Kingdom and pursuing the same mission. Healthy pastors learn to celebrate what God is doing through other churches and leaders without feeling threatened by their success.
Most importantly, we need people who will carry the weight with us. No pastor was designed to be the only person steering the church.
For our conversation: Who are you intentionally developing right now? If you unexpectedly had to step away from ministry for three months, what would continue functioning well without you? What would immediately struggle?
(5) Handle Conflict and Change Without Losing Your Footing
Eventually, ministry will test every leadership principle we claim to believe.
There will be conflict. There will be criticism. There will be decisions that do not work. There will be people who leave. There will be changes we did not choose and problems we did not create. There will even be moments when we take hits we genuinely did not deserve.
The challenge is learning how to respond without allowing those experiences to define us. Sometimes we need to stand firm. Sometimes we need to give in. Sometimes protecting the health of the church requires addressing something quickly. Other times maintaining unity is more important than winning the argument.
Failure is part of leadership too. A setback is not necessarily a verdict on our calling. Sometimes it is simply information. We tried something. It did not work. We learned. We adjust. We keep going.
Change is equally unavoidable. God does not change, but ministry constantly does. People change. Communities change. Churches change. Methods change. Expectations change. Healthy pastors learn to distinguish between the things that must never change and the things we simply prefer not to change.
For our conversation: What conflict, disappointment, or change is consuming the most emotional energy in your ministry right now? What would faithfulness look like in that situation, regardless of whether you “win”?
(6) Guard What You Cannot Get Back
Some things are difficult to rebuild once they are lost.
Integrity is one of them. Trust is another. Our closest relationships can be another.
Pastors need appropriate boundaries around money, relationships, decision-making and personal conduct. We should not place ourselves in situations where our integrity depends solely on our ability to resist temptation. Healthy structures, accountability, documentation and boundaries protect both the pastor and the church.
Our public ministry and private life also have to remain connected. A pastor who preaches one kind of life on Sunday but lives another during the week eventually damages far more than his own reputation. The people closest to us should not experience a completely different version of us than the people sitting in the congregation.
Learning to say no is part of protecting what matters. Every yes costs us something. Sometimes the most faithful decision we make is declining something good because saying yes would take us away from something more important.
For our conversation: What are you protecting carefully in this season? Is there anything valuable in your life or ministry that you have begun taking for granted?
(7) Stay Anchored in the Work That Matters
Ultimately, every leadership principle on this list depends on something deeper than leadership skill. We have to remain close to Christ.
Prayer cannot become something we do after we have exhausted every other option. One of the greatest dangers for any pastor is successfully leading people somewhere God never asked us to go. Prayer reminds us that this is His church, His mission and His people.
We also have to keep remembering why the church exists. Churches drift when activity replaces mission. Programs can continue, calendars can remain full, attendance can look respectable and budgets can remain balanced while the church slowly loses sight of why Jesus placed it in that community.
Scripture consistently calls church leaders toward humility. Peter instructed elders to lead by example rather than controlling the people entrusted to them (1 Peter 5:3). Paul described his ministry similarly, writing, “You see, we don’t go around preaching about ourselves. We preach that Jesus Christ is Lord, and we ourselves are your servants for Jesus’ sake” (2 Corinthians 4:5, NLT).
Through all of it, pastors have to continue loving the church. Not the imaginary church we wish we had. Not the church we remember from twenty years ago. Not the church we think we could build if everyone would simply cooperate. We are called to love the actual people God has entrusted to us. Then we keep going.
Finishing strong is not about maintaining a perfect record. No pastor gets everything right every week. It means remaining teachable, staying close to Christ, owning our mistakes, continuing to grow, loving people and remaining faithful through the hard seasons.
Around the Table
Look back over what you have read and identify the one or two questions that have your attention.
- Which lesson feels most relevant to your ministry right now? Why?
- Where have you learned one of these lessons the hard way?
- Which lesson do you wish someone had taught you during your first few years of ministry?
- Is there an area where you know what healthy leadership looks like but are struggling to actually practice it?
- What is something you are carrying right now that the pastors around this table could help you carry?
- What is one conversation, decision, boundary, or change you sense God asking you to make because of what we have discussed today?
We do not need to solve everything before we leave the table. Sometimes the most important thing a coaching group can provide is a place where pastors can say out loud what they have been carrying quietly.
Let’s give each other that kind of space.